THE
BUSINESS OF THE Board of Directors IS BUSINESS By James Verdonik
If you listen only to National
Public Radio or other media, you might think that the only purpose
of a Board of Directors is to approve astronomically high salaries
for the Board’s "cronies" including the CEO and other
high level managers.
While one of the functions
of corporate Boards is to approve the CEO’s (and other high level
managers’) compensation, that is certainly not the only function.
Likewise, although attorneys
tend to describe the Board of Directors in terms of legal duties,
during most Board meetings legal issues are only incidental to the
matters discussed by the Board. The primary function of the Board
of Directors is to ensure the corporation operates its business
in a way that is most beneficial to its shareholders. That means
the business of the Board is taking care of business.
Strategic Direction and
Supervisory Role
The Board of Directors
is charged with determining the strategic direction of the corporation
and supervising the business of the corporation. The key word here
is "supervising". Although Board members are sometimes
drawn into implementation, supervising generally involves choosing
others to implement, giving them directions and ascertaining whether
the implementation is effective in achieving the goals.
The monitoring and supervising
part of the Directors’ job is perhaps the most difficult and time
consuming. The Directors must track the performance of the CEO,
COO, CFO and other high level managers to ensure that the Board’s
strategic decisions are carried out. As outside directors spend
only a short time meeting with management, they must assimilate
large amounts of information and make decisions quickly. This requires
the Board to review information before each Board meeting so that
they are prepared to act at the meeting.
Outside Directors vS. Inside
Directors
The Board also must supervise
the management of actual and potential conflicts of interest and
monitor the integrity of the company’s accounting systems and oversee
financial disclosure and corporate communications.
In order to perform these
business functions, it is useful that the majority of Directors
be "outside" Directors who are not from inside the company
and have no business ties to the company or its management team.
Outside Directors who are not involved in the day to day operations
of the corporation often provide valuable perspective from a distance
and challenge assumptions that management makes. Having outside
Directors is also useful because inside Directors may on occasion
advocate their own interests to the detriment of shareholders. Also,
the Board of Directors looks at the corporation as a whole, whereas
many officers concentrate on their own particular area, such as
marketing, manufacturing, R&D or human resources. The Board's
responsibility goes beyond whether each individual area is being
handled effectively to whether all areas combined are causing the
corporation to achieve the overall goal.
Setting Major Policies
The Board of Directors
is charged with setting major policies for the corporation. Major
policies include a wide range of areas. The Board spends most of
its limited time addressing the following essential business.
Strategic Direction.
The Board should decide what markets the Company should pursue and
what products or services to sell to those markets. Although management
makes recommendations to the Board, the Board determines the areas
to which the marketing and advertising as well as research and development
should be allocated. Once these decisions are made, the Board continually
monitors the Company’s progress and determines what changes need
to be made.
Growth. The Board
should make strategic decisions regarding the rate of growth, timing
for growth and the manner of growth of the Company. Directors also
decide whether to grow by acquisition or by internal development.
Resource Allocation.
The Board should decide which part of the business should receive
funds and for which purposes. The strategic decisions regarding
whether to re-invest profits or to pay dividends and in what amount
and when is made by the Board.
Budgets/Business Plans.
The Board should ensure that the corporate budget is based on
reasonable assumptions, is adequate to achieve the strategic goals
of the corporation and is reasonable in light of financial resources.
Personnel Decisions.
The Board also makes decisions like hiring and firing the CEO
(and other officers) and compensation. A proactive Board will also
seek to motivate management to maximize performance.
Finance. The Board
should be proactive in anticipating the future capital needs of
the company and determining when capital can be raised at the lowest
cost. This function is vital to both enable the company to have
the resources it needs to achieve its business plan and to avoid
unnecessary dilution to shareholders.
Debt. One way to
avoid dilution to existing shareholders is to borrow so that additional
shares do not have to be sold to finance growth. Debt, however,
has a first priority claim over the shareholders to the assets of
the corporation. Therefore, taking on excessive debt can mean that
the shareholders risk losing ownership of corporate assets. The
Board must decide between the benefits of debt and its risks in
determining whether to borrow and how much to borrow.
Financial Reporting/Accounting.
The Board has an obligation to ensure the integrity of the corporation's
financial information, which is important for both internal decision
making and external disclosure. This means ensuring that the corporation
has adequate systems in place for generating accurate financial
information and that the financial statements of the corporation
reflect proper accounting practices. Although the Board can rely
on accounting experts, the Board must supervise the process and
ensure that any deficiencies are corrected.
Securities Compliance.
The Board should ensure that accurate and full disclosure is
made to all investors and shareholders in SEC filings, press releases
and otherwise. The Board should also ensure the corporation has
policies in place to prevent insider trading.
Shareholder Relations.
The Board should oversee shareholder relations and communications.
Part of this investor relations function is to monitor the stock
market's perception of the company and its stock price. The Board
should ensure that management gets the company's story to financial
markets in a way that causes the markets to fairly value the company.
Directors should supervise and monitor the manner and substance
of communications with the company’s shareholders and investors,
whether the communications are in the form of SEC documents, press
releases or articles on a web-site.
Liquidity and Exit
Strategies. The Board should focus on the shareholders' natural
desire for liquidity. This means developing a strategy for sale
or IPO of the company or for paying dividends and evaluating all
corporate action in light of whether it advances or hinders achieving
the strategy.
Mistakes and Changes.
The Board must decide when it and management have made mistakes
and must change direction in light of new facts.
Professional Advisers.
The Board must ensure that the professional advisers to the
corporation (accountants, attorneys, investment bankers, etc.) have
the ability and expertise that is adequate for the corporation's
needs and that will enable the Board to reasonably rely on their
advice as experts. The Board must ensure that its professional advisers
continue to be adequate as the corporation grows and faces new challenges.
Adding Value
Surveys say that
investors are more likely to invest in companies with good governance
than they are to invest in companies with equivalent financial performance
and weak governance. Because of the Board’s ability to attract capital
to companies, a good Board, above all, will add value.
Weak Boards. A
weak Board can be afflicted with an array of maladies, including
poor management of its own operations, inappropriate constituency
(personal or professional backgrounds of Directors are less than
ideal- the "idiot brother-in-law" problem) and bad blood
between the Board and the management of the company. Non-value adding
Boards are deferential, reactive and focused on process instead
of aggressively taking the initiative. Weak Boards also often have
too many members with the same kind of experience and expertise.
They do a few things well, but not the broad range of issues that
Boards must supervise.
Strong Boards. For
a Board to add value, it should be pro-active and anticipate changes
in the market instead of merely focusing on historical data. Successful
Boards are forward thinking. They motivate management to solve problems
before they appear instead of merely analyzing what went wrong after
the fact. Strong Boards generally include members who have experience
in a wide range of areas so that the collective wisdom of the Board
is broad enough to address the wide range of business matters the
Board must deal with.
Partners. Management
and the Board of Directors should work with one another as partners,
not opponents. To add value, Boards must question the proposals
of executives, strategize and assess risks instead of merely rubber
stamping management proposals. At the same time, questions should
be posed in ways that do not unnecessarily alienate management and
some deference should be given to the depth of knowledge management
has about the company and its industry.