CASHING OUT: TURNING STOCK INTO CASH By James Verdonik
Bill Gates, the richest man in the world, has most of his wealth
tied up in Microsoft stock, which he cannot sell without complying
with securities laws. Our own Research Triangle includes many "paper
millionaires," who are stock rich, but cash poor. This article
addresses how to turn stock into cash.
You need to know the rules to resell securities
if:
You are the founder of a hot young technology
company that you hope will go public.
You invested in a hot young technology
company that you hope will go public.
You work for a company that grants stock
options to employees.
You are an executive trying to incentivize
your team by granting stock options or other forms of equity compensation.
You are selling your company to a public company in exchange for
shares of the acquiring company's stock.
A basic principle of securities laws is that
securities cannot be sold without either a registration with the
Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") or an exemption
from registration. For determining whether securities can be resold,
the world is divided into two basic types of securities: restricted
securities and unrestricted securities. Restricted securities are
securities that have been acquired from the company that issues
the securities without a registration, or from an officer, director
or other affiliates of the issuer. Unrestricted securities can be
resold without restrictions except by affiliates.
Registration the securities,
A common misperception about securities is
that after a company conducts its IPO, all its shares are registered.
Generally, this is not the case. In most IPOs, the company registers
new shares and does not register any, or only a small percentage
of, the shares held by its officers, directors and pre-IPO investors.
Consequently, the IPO does not allow the company's shareholders
to sell all their shares. Investors often have contractual rights
(negotiated at the time of their investment) to require a company
to register their shares, but officers, directors and employees
generally do not have registration rights.
Employees who have been granted stock options
generally have their shares registered for resale by their employer
utilizing a registration statement on Form S-8, which is a short
form of registration statement that can be completed quickly and
less expensively than other registration statements. Resales of
registered stock by employees other than officers and directors
of the issuer can be made freely without restriction.
Exemptions From Registration
Rule 144 is the most common exemption from
registration used for resales by officers, directors and purchasers
of shares in private placements. Under Rule 144, some shares can
be sold 90 days after the company's IPO if the shares have been
owned by the seller for at least one year. Sales are subject to
a volume limitation so that in any calendar quarter a shareholder
may not sell more than 1% of the outstanding shares owned by all
shareholders of the company. Selling pursuant to Rule 144 can delay
a sale because of the paperwork involved, including a filing with
the SEC. You should, therefore, contact your broker in advance.
Also, the broker often charges a higher commission to compensate
for the extra paperwork.
Rule 701 allows resales of shares granted
to employees before the company's IPO. The number of shares a company
can issue to employees is limited as stated in Rule 701. Resales
by officers, directors and other affiliates of the company are subject
to the 1% volume limitations of Rule 144, but are not subject to
the holding period requirements of Rule 144. This relief from the
holding period requirement allows resales of stock acquired upon
exercise of stock options without holding the underlying stock for
a year after exercise of the stock option, which otherwise would
be required in a Rule 144 resale.
When a company acquires another company by
exchanging shares of stock, the acquiring company can register the
shares on Form S-4. If no registration is made by the issuer, Rule
145 allows former shareholders of the acquired company to sell shares
by complying with Rule 144 (including the volume limitation) but
without the usual one-year holding period.
Lock Ups
In addition to the securities law restrictions
on resales of securities discussed above, officers, directors and
other holders of large blocks of stock are usually required by investment
bankers to sign agreements (called Lockup Agreements) not to resell
their stock for an agreed period of time after the company's IPO.
The shares are usually "locked up" for a period of 180
days after completion of the IPO. If, however, the investment bankers
believe a company is at a very early stage and presents a higher
risk profile for investors, the lockup period may last as long as
two years. Lockups serve two purposes. First, the standard 180-day
lockup period protects the underwriters against new shares flooding
the public markets and lowering the market price during a period
in which the underwriters may be purchasing and selling shares to
stabilize the market. Second, longer lockups of a year or two are
designed to reassure investors that insiders will not immediately
dump their shares and walk away from the company before the company
achieves certain growth goals. Investors are reassured that they
can give the company up to two years to perform and still cash out
before the insiders can sell their shares.
Other Restrictions:
Other securities law restrictions on the resale
of securities include:
Section 16 restricts officers, directors
and 10% shareholders from selling within 6 months after a purchase
of stock at a lower price.
Rule 10b-5 prohibits anyone from reselling
shares at a time when the reseller is in possession of material
nonpublic information. In some small public companies, where material
events occur frequently, officers, directors and key employees
may be able to sell on only a few days during an entire year because
of Rule 10b-5.
In summary, there are many impediments to
turning securities into cash. Companies, officers, directors, investors
and employees should consult with their legal and financial advisors
to develop a plan to allow them to sell securities in compliance
with securities laws, while at the same time addressing their tax,
estate planning, asset protection, and other related objectives.
Addressing these issues the day before you want to cash out may
be too late. Advanced planning with professionals is usually required
to achieve your goals.