Investment banks come in a wide range
of sizes and play different roles. Each can assist your company
in different ways.
· Business Brokers. At one end of the investment banking
industry is the business broker. These companies can assist
you to either buy or sell a small business. Although business
brokers sometimes are involved in larger transactions, transaction
sizes typically are in the range of $50,000 to $1 million.
· Placement Agents. Placement agents assist companies
to find investors. Typically, the investors are wealthy individuals
and the deal sizes are in the range of $50,000 to $5 Million.
Some placement agents work alone at home on one or two deals
a year. Others are companies with many professionals, who
do dozens of placements each year.
· Investment Banks. Investment banks typically perform
the same functions as business brokers or placement agents,
but focus on larger transactions, provide a higher degree
of specialization and a wider range of services. In most cases,
investment banks also either offer retail brokerage services
and investment adviser services or are affiliated with a company
that offers these services.
It's useful to think of three categories of investment banks:
general purpose, regional and specialized. Regional investment
banks focus on one section of the country. Specialized investment
banks focus on one or several industries or types of deals.
General Purpose investment banks usually are very large and
offer a wide range of services worldwide.
Finding someone who can sell your deal can be almost as difficult
as finding investors. If your company is very early stage
and the amount to be raised is under $1 million, it's difficult
to interest a professional investment banker, even at the
smallest firms. Some individuals do raise seed capital for
companies. Their success record is sporadic. Don't rely exclusively
on any single informal agent and don't think the agent will
sell your deal. Usually, finders only make introductions.
You still have to personally sell investors on doing the deal.
Always get your agreement with a finder in writing. Make sure
your agreement clearly states you only have to pay if you
close a deal and receive money.
(3)
What can investment
bankers do for my company?
Investment banks can assist your
company to do the following:
· do an IPO or other public securities offering
· sell securities in a private placement to institutional
investors at a higher price than venture capital investors
will pay
· identify and assist you to negotiate a joint venture,
strategic alliance or sale of your company with a Fortune
1000 company or their foreign equivalent
· identify smaller companies for your company to purchase
in a roll-up or other acquisition strategy
· assist the founder to sell a block of stock to diversify
assets
· implement a put/call strategy for the founders of
a public company to manage the risk of holding most of their
assets in a volatile young public company
· create a stronger trading market for your company's
stock by issuing analyst reports or making a market in your
company's stock
· create a public market for the stock of a private
company by making a market in the stock on the OTC Bulletin
Board
· issue a fairness opinion to help insulate a board
of directors from liability in a securities or other transaction
Hiring the most prestigious investment banker doesn't necessarily
translate into greater value or better service for your company.
Value and service will generally depend on whether there is
a good match between the strengths of the investment bank
you use and the needs of your company. This underscores the
need to interview and do your due diligence before you select
an investment banker.
Selecting the right investment banker for your company will
include factors such as the following:
· is the bank interested in companies of your size
or in your size transaction?
· does the bank have an investment analyst who is recognized
as being strong in your industry and will that analyst issue
reports about your company?
· does the investment bank's customer base match the
types of investors you are seeking (for example, retail vs.
institutional investors or U.S. vs. international)?
· does the investment bank have a good record of supporting
the market price after the transaction is over?
· is the investment bank strong in other financial
services your company needs?
(5)
What
questions should I ask investment bankers during the selection
process?
You need to do extensive due diligence before you hire an
investment banker. Questions you should ask include the following:
· Who Will Sell Your Deal? The investment bankers
you meet at the "pitch" are not necessarily the
ones who will do the work. These senior bankers are very experienced
and have impressive resumes. However, in many cases you will
spend your time dealing with bankers who are a year or two
out of business school. Ask to meet and interview the team.
Also, ask the senior people to described exactly what roles
they will play. Get the home and cell phone numbers of the
senior people and use them as needed throughout the deal.
· Industry Experience. Ask what other companies
the bankers have represented in your industry. Have them create
a list with the type of deal for each industry client. Success
in selling is increasingly dependent on knowledge about special
industry markets and which investors are interested in each
market. Don't make a decision based on a generic deals list
that's not industry specific.
· Conflicts of Interest. Ask the bankers whether
they represent any of your competitors. Ask them to check
their data base. You may not want to educate them with your
confidential information, if they're advising a competitor.
Ask what happens to you if a larger competitor is doing a
bigger deal and wants the banker to drop you. Get confirmation
they will continue working for you.
· Registration. Investment bankers are subject
to extensive government regulation. Most states require them
to register with the state securities regulators. Many small
placement agents and finders fail to register. Ask whether
the banker is registered in all the states in which securities
are to be sold. Check with the securities regulators about
whether there have been any securities violations by the placement
agent or finder.
· Clients. Ask for references to clients of
the investment banker. Ask for references to both clients
whose deal closed and clients whose deals did not close.
Investment bankers generally charge four types of fees: cash
retainers, cash reimbursement of expenses, cash as a percentage
of the transaction and equity compensation.
· Cash for Expenses. Some investment bankers
charge expenses that exceed the actual expenses related to
the transaction in the form of a fixed expense allowance that's
not refundable even if the actual expenses are lower. A fixed
expense allowance is usually a profit center for investment
bankers and may be a way of charging a retainer fee without
calling it a retainer fee.
· Retainers Some investment bankers charge
a monthly cash retainer, as well as the percentage fee payable
at closing. Usually the retainer can be applied as a credit
that reduces the amount of the percentage fee payable at the
closing. With the retainer, the investment banker reduces
its risk by receiving some compensation whether or not a deal
closes. Try to minimize the retainer part of the fee.
· Cash Fees. The cash fee paid upon the closing
of the transaction is usually based on a percentage of the
money raised in the offering or a percentage of the sales
price of your company. Percentages vary from one deal to the
next, but the range for a private placement is generally 5%
to 10%. For larger deals, a "Lehman" formula is
sometimes used, which charges a lower percentage as the amount
raised increases. For example 5% of the first million dollars,
4% of the second million dollars, 3% of the third million,
2% of the fourth million and 1% above four million. The "Double
Lehman" formula uses 10%, 8%, 6%, 4% and 2%. The dollar
break points at which the percentage is reduced are negotiable
and vary from one deal to the next.
· Equity Compensation. Most equity compensation
paid to investment bankers is in the form of warrants. The
warrants are generally for a number of shares equal to between
5% and 10% of the number of shares sold in the deal. The warrants
usually have an exercise price equal to 100% to 120% of the
price of the securities sold in the deal. Sometimes all or
part of the cash fee is converted into stock.
(7)
What
factors affect compensation in particular transactions?
Although investment banking fees for most transactions contain
a combination of expense reimbursement, cash fee and warrants,
the amount in each category of fees varies from deal to deal
depending upon a number of factors, including the following:
· Size of the Deal. The general rule is the lower
the dollar amount to be raised, the higher the percentage
the investment banker receives. This is the case because the
amount of time and effort it takes to raise $25 million is
often not much more than it takes to raise $5 million.
· Stage of Company. With younger companies there is
usually greater risk the deal will not close or will take
unexpected effort by the investment banker. Therefore, bankers
charge a higher fee.
· Industry. If your company is in a hot industry, the
investment banker may agree to a lower fee because the deal
will be easier to sell. Also, the warrants may be deemed to
be more valuable.
· Market Factors. If a company has no other visible
sources of funding, the fee will generally be higher than
if other investment bankers are competing for your business
or if the company's existing investors are willing to fund
the company.
(8)
How
can I incentivize my investment banker to get me the best deal
terms?
Although the size of the fee is important, it's often more
important to assure that the fee is structured so that the
investment banker has an incentive to get the deal closed
on terms favorable to you. It may be in your interest, therefore,
to agree to a percentage fee that is at the low end of the
normal range, but to agree to a higher fee if at closing the
deal meets specified valuation criteria. For example, 10%
if the pre-money valuation at closing is twenty million or
more and 5% if the pre-money valuation is less than $20 million.
(9)
Are there standard terms and issues for investment banking fee
agreements?
The following provisions and issues arise in most investment
banking agreements:
· Exclusivity. Most investment banks require
exclusive rights to sell securities for a stated time period,
generally in the range of three months to six months, but
it can be longer. Although some freelance placement agents
or brokers are willing to work on a nonexclusive basis, it's
generally futile to attempt to get a reputable investment
banker to agree to work on a nonexclusive basis. In some larger
deals, similar to IPO's in scope, however, the deal may have
a second investment banker or a co-manger.
· Term. Most contracts have a term of three
months to one year. Being tied to a banker who is not producing
can harm your company. You should seek to be able to terminate
on thirty days notice.
· Tails. Most investment bankers insist on being
paid for money received after their services are terminated,
if it's raised from investors they introduced. This provision
is called the "tail." The duration of the "tail"
varies from one deal to another, but one year is the most
common. In some cases (especially for longer tails), the investment
banker's fee is reduced as time goes on.
· Company Investors. A company seeking to raise
$10 million may know it can sell $2 million to existing investors
or to potential investors it already knows. Investment bankers
often seek to earn a fee on such sales. In many cases, however,
they will agree to a reduced fee for these sales. In other
cases, no fee is paid.
· Investor Selection Process. Control both the
number and the nature of investors an investment banker contacts
to sell your deal. The agreement should require the investment
banker to contact only potential investors you have approved.
· Indemnification. Standard investment banking
agreements require the company to indemnify the banker against
any claim even if the banker was negligent. On the other hand,
investment bankers usually do not indemnify companies for
the banker's misdeeds. This may not seem fair or balanced,
but it's standard and you just have to live with it.
· Follow on Deals. Investment bankers often seek
the right to represent companies in later transactions, including
a later IPO or sale of the company. Later, when a transaction
occurs, the company may have to make economic concessions
to the banker to obtain a waiver. In many cases, the banker
can be persuaded to drop this provision.